French    German    Spain    Italian    Arabic    Chinese Simplified    Russian

Western Civilisation

Join Gab (@StFerdinandIII) Western Civilisation was and is superior to anything Islam has developed.  Islam has not aided in the development of the modern world; in fact civilisation has only been created in spite of Islam.  Raising the alarm about the fascism called Submission since 2000.  

Back     Printer Friendly Version  

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Bookmark and Share

Martin Gilbert: 'In Ishmael's House: A History of Jews in Muslim Lands', part 2.

Inter-faith cultural harmony and nirvana, it was not.

by Ferdinand III


Published in 2010, this book is the best one volume account outlining the history of Jews in Muslim lands including the effects of Dhimmitude – a form of servile second class status to Muslims, that many in the West are so eager to live under. The first review is here. In this second profile we can look at the early origins of the Dhimma contract, first instituted of course upon the Khaibar Jews by Mohammed when he attacked them, unprovoked, under the cover of darkness and after butchering some of their undefended men, gave the Jews a clear choice – submit to Muslim rule as second class slaves, in which 'Islam' [in which Allah and Mohammed are the same of course] owns the land and the production; or die. Pretty simple choice. Nothing nuanced or complicated about that offer. The Jews of Khaibar accepted Dhimmitude, hence the cry today from Muslims when they taunt Jews 'Remember Khaibar'. Remember your slave-status Jew. We will impose the dhimma contract upon you. Dhimmitude is of course a necessary part of tolerance, love and inter-faith harmony is it not?

One of the brilliant aspects of this book, is that Gilbert's facts speak for themselves. For example he lists the history of early Jewish Dhimmitude without making, as I would most certainly, any 'conclusions', and offers no real commentary. His motto; just the facts sir. And the facts are by themselves rather complete and informative. Jews were not only humiliated within Islamic lands from the 7th century onwards; hundreds of thousands or more were forcibly converted to Islam. Pogroms were common, the deaths of Jews a regular occurrence. The capricious character of Moslem rule might mean some self-interested toleration of Jews in commerce, government, the military or in medicine [the most famous doctors in Islamic history were Jews]. But too often the need to tax, to find 'scapegoats', to punish 'ostentatious displays' and to enforce the humiliating second class contract, meant that Jews were assaulted, beaten or killed. There is no denying this. How many Jews were converted or killed by Moslems post 637 AD? Mr. Gilbert does not offer an answer. It is a question that should be answered. The body count of Jewish dead and converted is an important aspect of Jewish history.

And what of Christian anti-semiticism one asks? It is factually true that from 400 to 1097 AD that Jews and Christians lived in tenuous harmony. No pogroms were enacted. This changed after the Islamic invasions. Anti-semiticism which is an important plank in the Moslem political theology, was carried into Christian lands. It is thus a Moslem invention as is Holy War. It is also true that the Jews did aid the Moslems in their successful assault on the Byzantine empire and its key cities in the early days of Moslem imperialism; and later in the Moslem takeover of Visigothic Spain. In fact the Moslem capture of key Spanish or Gothic cities such as Toledo is attributable in large measure to Jewish help. This 5th column activity, would of course quite rightly stoke anti-semiticism in Christian lands during the Middle Ages [something that Mr. Gilibert does not say, but seems to be an obvious fact]. I am not sure how it could be avoided. The allies of your enemy are apparently your enemy. It is also clear that many Jews mistakenly viewed the Moslems, at least in the beginning, as liberators or potential allies against the anti-semitic Byzantine church [which during the time of Heraclius in the 630s AD had started to forcibly convert Jews to Christianity as a reprisal for the Jews helping the Persians capture Jerusalem and large parts of the Byzantine empire].

While the Jews may have welcomed the Moslems in the Levant and elsewhere, the cult of Mohammed viewed the Jews – as Mohammed himself did – as nothing else other than a group to be plundered, taxed and humiliated. The contract of 'Umar or Omar dating from around 640 AD, and written after the Moslem occupation of Jerusalem codifies Mohammed's and Islam's supremacist might over the Christians and Jews:

...Covenant of Omar, which almost certainly dated from this period, and which formally categorized non-Muslims as ahl al-dhimma – 'the People of the Pact'......dhimmis had to pay the jiyza tax to the local ruler and accept the conditions...”

I am sure a PhD somewhere will conflate Omar's oppressive regulations with the US Constitution. Jews were subservient to Moslems. Period.

...They were even obliged to carry signs on their clothing or to wear types and colours of clothing that would indicate they were not Muslims, while at the same time avoid clothing that had any association with Mohammed and Islam. Most notably, green clothing was forbidden.....The property of a dhimmi who died was to belong to the Muslim authorities – not to the dhimmi's community – unitl the heirs could prove their right to it under Islamic (Sharia Law)....A non Muslim man could not marry a Muslim woman.”

Oppression of Jews by Moslems in Moslem states, and the forcible conversion of Jews including Jewish boys and orphans to Islam, were rampant. Jews might rise and do well in Moslem states. In the areas of finance and medicine as Mr. Gilbert states, the Jews could do very well. A Jew was even a vizier in the Ottoman empire, and Jews were also generals in Moslem armies. But in the main, for the average Jew, the Moslem dhimma-contract was anything but a 'ladder up'. It usually with variations in time and space, made them vulnerable to Moslem predations:

The exclusion and persecution of non-Muslims depended on the severity or leniency of individual Muslim rulers....In Baghdad for Abbasid Caliphs were particularly strict in their interpretation of the dhimmi laws: Harun al-Rashid (786-809)......al-Mutawakkil (847-861). In two decrees, one in 850 and the other in 854, al-Mutawakkil ordered Christians and Jews to fix wooden images of devils to their houses...”

Now the modern cultural Marxist and howling socialist will tell you that the above era was a 'Golden Age' of Islam [a myth of course]. Rashid is the famed ruler from 'Arabian Nights', a man who was the most glorious and serene monarch in the world at that time....or so we are told. In reality the enactment of dhimma laws during his reign and indeed for most of the 9th century was harsh in the extreme. I don't recall too many historians, media personalities or academics bemoaning the utter humiliation of Christians and Jews who had to afix images of the devil to their homes, or engage in the most ritualized and debasing of dhimmi practices, including in many cases, the payment of the jiyza or head tax in person to the local Muslim ruler, from a prostrated position [a fact which Mr. Gilbert does not reference unfortunately]. The entire ethos of Dhimmitude is to humiliate the subject in question. As the Koran says, 'make them feel subjugated'. Dhimma laws are thus simply employing what Mohammed [who is Allah] wanted – the destruction of Jewish will.

Dhimmitude was in reality a vicious assault on Jews. We know this from the extant records and sources which Mr. Gilbert uses. Historically the entire Mediterranean went into economic and political decline after the Arab conquests. Out of this was birthed the myth and lies about Europe's Dark Ages. The political-economy and social infrastructure in both Western Europe and Byzantine went into a depression. Trade patterns were obstructed or stopped. Papyrus from Egypt was not exported any longer to the Christian world necessitating the use of hides or parchment for writing [facts which Mr. Gilbert does not mention]. Cities and economies went into decline. The wheel was lost in Egypt for 3 centuries. Both Western European and Byzantine sources confirm this general malaise. Thus the Jews in Jerusalem, along with the city's economy began to disappear after 750 and 'When Jerusalem was later conquered by Egyptian Muslims in 878, the city's Jews were persecuted by their rulers, who enforced the dhimmi laws with extreme rigor.' This pattern was repeated for the next 1000 years. Jews either fled areas of Moslem persecution or felt compelled to convert to Islam.

The cultural attitudes of Moslems towards Jews was also one of denigration and ridicule. A fact still witnessed today by Arabs and Moslems who jeer at Jews and demonize Jews in general or in particular. This cultural attitude gives rise to intolerance, pogroms and a general demonization of the Jew as either a non-human [a pig, a cattle, a donkey], or as a human who is inferior [Hitler's untermenschen]. In either case the Jew becomes a prey to whatever a Moslem desires. Quoting historian David Lewis, Mr Gilbert writes:

'Muslim tolerance was based more on condescension than on generosity.'

And,

Where there was no such law prohibiting robbery, Rabbi Hai wrote that all Muslims 'must be regarded as extortionists and thieves'.

The cultural animus towards Jews was wide and deep in the Islamic world. Under something as repressive as a dhimma contract, this must certainly be an obvious truth. Such attitudes could and did give rise to generational pogroms against the followers of Moses:

'[1066 Granada]...there was a savage attack by local Muslims on the Jewish population of Granada, in which an estimated five thousand Jews were murdered'.

Cultural Marxists use Granada as the exemplar of Moslem greatness. How than to explain the above, which is only one pogrom in this city out of half a dozen which transpired over 800 years. In todays world, the Jews would be blamed for the Muslim mob's murders. If only [insert here] had not existed or if only the Jews had not [insert here]; than the peaceful Muslim mob in Granada would have continued to embrace them in the fellowship of love and tolerance. Or something like that.

In any event it is an enlightening and disturbing read. Jews in Moslem lands were not heralded as equals by Moslems. They were viewed as chattel, tax producing knaves and second-class slaves. Maybe Moslems can explain this to us ?  If Islam is charity and tolerance, how to explain the existence of Dhimmis and the dhimma contract ? More to come from Mr. Gilbert. 


Article Comments:

Related Articles:

Books Reviewed


3/20/2021:  Bearing False Witness, by Rodney Stark, #2.

3/17/2021:  Bearing False Witness, by Rodney Stark, #1.

2/5/2021:  ‘Slavery, Terrorism and Islam’ by Peter Hammond

1/27/2021:  Emmet Scott 'The Impact of Islam' and the mythical Golden Age of Muhammadan Spain

1/24/2021:  The Impact of Islam, by Emmet Scott (part two)

1/20/2021:  The Impact of Islam, by Emmet Scott (part one)

10/16/2020:  The Age of Plunder, by W. G. Hoskins

9/8/2020:  The Glory of the Crusades, Steve Weidenkopf (2014)

8/5/2020:  C.S. Lewis and 'The Abolition of Man' by Steve Turley

12/18/2019:  The Palestinian Delusion: The Catastrophic History of the Middle East Peace Process, Robert Spencer

12/11/2019:  Islam: Religion of Peace?: The Violation of Natural Rights and Western Cover-Up, Fr. Portella

11/25/2019:  2030: Your Children's Future in Islamic Britain, by David Vincent

2/24/2016:  Morris Bishop, 'The Middle Ages'

8/18/2015:  Dr. Robert Morey, 'Islam Unveiled' – The Real Desert Storm

8/16/2015:  R. A. Morey, 'Islam Unveiled', 1991

1/18/2015:  Ataturk in the Nazi Imagination, by Stefan Ihrig

11/28/2014:  The poorly named Enlightenment - James Hitchcock, History of the Catholic Church

11/27/2014:  Michael Coren's 'Hatred: Islam's war against Christianity' Read it.

11/14/2014:  Michael Coren: 'Hatred; Islam's war on Christianity'. Stating the obvious.

11/11/2014:  Collins and Christian-Catholic Culture in the West

11/4/2014:  The Birth of the West: Rome, Germany, France, the Creation of Europe in the 10th Century P. Collins

7/25/2014:  James Hitchcock, The History of the Catholic Church

7/19/2014:  William Muir, 1868, 'Life of Mahomet' - the madness revealed

6/30/2014:  Garwood: 'Flat Earth' - a belief only held by atheists and evolutionists

3/25/2014:  John Freely: 'Before Galileo', Diophantus to Bradwardine, review 2

3/15/2014:  Book Review: John Freely and 'Before Galileo'

2/19/2014:  Christianity, Islam and Atheism by William Kilpatrick (2)

2/18/2014:  Christianity, Islam and Atheism by William Kilpatrick

6/28/2013:  Raymond Ibrahim 'Crucified Again: Exposing Islam's New War on Christians'

4/24/2013:  Evangelical Catholicism: Deep Reform in the 21st-Century Church by George Weigel

4/21/2013:  Robert Spencer: 'Moslem Persecution of Christians'

4/13/2013:  Book Review: Islam: Evil in the name of God

3/31/2013:  The Triumph of the Risen. The Truth of Christianity.

1/12/2013:  Book Review 2: God and Reason In the Middle Ages, by Edward Grant

1/7/2013:  Book Review 1: God and Reason In the Middle Ages, by Edward Grant

1/3/2013:  The Early Middle Ages 400-1000, Editor Rosamund McKitterick, Short Oxford History of Europe

12/17/2012:  Heresy: Ten Lies They Spread About Christianity, by Michael Coren

12/10/2012:  Medieval Technology and Social Change, Lynn White Jr., Oxford Press, 1968

11/29/2012:  Book Review: Preachers of Hate: Islam and the War on America, Kenneth Timmerman

11/28/2012:  Book Review: Islamophobia, by Robert Spencer.

11/25/2012:  Part 2: The Gies' - Cathedral, Forge and Waterwheel, Review

11/23/2012:  The Gies': Cathedral, Forge and Waterwheel, Review.

11/13/2012:  Book: The cult of the Moon God, by Brian Wilson

10/31/2012:  Review 2: Islam Dismantled, Sujit Das, Ali Sina

10/29/2012:  Book Review 1: Islam Dismantled by Sujit Das, Ali Sina

9/22/2012:  Book Review: Michael Coren, 'Why Catholics are Right'.

9/3/2012:  Book Review, Why the West is Best, by Ibn Warraq, Part Two

8/29/2012:  Book Review, Why the West is Best, by Ibn Warraq, Part One

6/12/2012:  Book Review: Poitiers AD 732, Charles Martel turns the Islamic tide. David Nicolle.

6/6/2012:  Review 2: Diane Moczar, Islam at the Gates, How Christendom defeated the Ottoman Turks

5/31/2012:  Review 1: Diane Moczar, Islam at the Gates, How Christendom defeated the Ottoman Turks

5/26/2012:  The Early Middle Ages 400-1000, Editor Rosamund McKitterick, Short Oxford History of Europe

4/13/2012:  Review, Emmet Scott: 'Mohammed and Charlemagne'

4/10/2012:  Henri Pirenne, 'Mohammed and Charlemagne' – Part 2

4/7/2012:  Book Review: Henri Pirenne, Mohammed and Charlemagne – Part One

1/29/2012:  Andrew Wheatcroft's, 'The Enemy at the Gate'

1/22/2012:  Book Review: Defenders of the Faith, by James Reston Jr.

1/11/2012:  Book Review: Norman Berdichevsky, 'The Left is not always Right'

12/10/2011:  Book Review, Nigel Cliff's 'Holy War' – good but flawed.

11/7/2011:  'How Civilizations Die', D. P. Goldman, 2011, 270 pgs.

9/29/2011:  Book Review: Bynum's 'Allah is Dead'

9/16/2011:  Middle Age Dynamism

8/13/2011:  Malise Ruthven, 'Islam in the World' and the Kabaa-Hajj paganism.

8/12/2011:  EJ Brill and the Ka'ba

8/11/2011:  F.E. Peters and the pagan origins of the Kabaa Shrine

7/14/2011:  Benjamin Walker, Foundations of Islam: The Making of a World Faith 

4/12/2011:  Martin Gilbert: 'In Ishmael's House: A History of Jews in Muslim Lands', part 3.

4/6/2011:  Martin Gilbert: 'In Ishmael's House: A History of Jews in Muslim Lands', part 2.

4/3/2011:  Review part 1: Martin Gilbert 'In Ishmael's House'. A History of Jews living in Muslim lands.

3/31/2011:  Book Review: Susan Bauer, 'The History of the Medieval World'

3/24/2011:  Book Review: Empires of the Sea, by Roger Crowley. [The Final Battle for the Mediterranean]

3/22/2011:  Book Review: Will Israel survive? By Dr. Mitchell Bard, expert on Israel's political-economy.

3/20/2011:  Book Review ‘The Great War for Civilization', by Robert Fisk

3/18/2011:  Book Review: Bruce Bawer's “Surrender: Appeasing Islam, Sacrificing Freedom”, Doubleday, May 2009.

3/15/2011:  Book Review: World War IV and Beyond, by Richard Hobbs.

3/11/2011:  Alan Dershowitz's: 'The Case for Israel.'

3/5/2011:  Leaving Islam, by Ibn Warraq

2/18/2011:  Review part 2: D. S. Margoliouth, 'The Early Development of Mohammedanism', 1913.

2/12/2011:  Review: D. S. Margoliouth, 'The Early Development of Mohammedanism', 1913.

12/21/2010:  Robert R. Reilly, 'The Closing of the Muslim Mind'. The Communal Fascism of Islam.

12/19/2010:  Robert R. Reilly, 'The Closing of the Muslim Mind'.

10/20/2010:  Andrew McCarthy, 'The Grand Jihad, How Islam and the Left Sabotage America'.

10/18/2010:  Book Review: 'The Dhimmi. Jews and Christians under Islam.' Bat Ye'or.

10/8/2010:  Jamie Glazov: 'United in Hate'. Indeed they are. The Leftards and Muslims that is.

8/31/2010:  'The Stealth Jihad: How Radical Islam is Subverting America without Guns or Bombs', Robert Spencer

8/9/2010:  Amil Imani: Iranian and former-Muslim writes about the pagan savagery that is Islam.

7/15/2010:  Book Review: Baran's 'The Other Muslims: Moderate and Secular'. A fantasy novel.

6/29/2010:  Serge Trifkovic: 'The Sword of the Prophet'. Jihad, Jihad and endless Jihad.

6/28/2010:  Serge Trifkovic: 'The Sword of the Prophet'. The Madness of Muhammad.

5/31/2010:  Fregosi and Islam's endless Jihad.

5/21/2010:  Book Review: 'Islam's Black Slaves', by Ronald Segal, 2001.

5/9/2010:  Book Review: 'Race and Slavery in the Middle East.' by Bernard Lewis, 1990.

5/6/2010:  Book Review: 'Slavery in the Arab World', by Murray Gordon, 1987.

5/5/2010:  Book Review: R. C Davis; 'Christian Slaves, Muslim Masters', 2004 edition.

5/1/2010:  Book review: The Complete Infidel's Guide to the Koran, by Robert Spencer.

4/9/2010:  Book Review: 'The Islamic Anti-Christ', Joel Richardson, 2009, WND Books.

3/26/2010:  Book Review: Wafa Sultan, 'A God Who Hates'. 2009, 244 pages.

3/19/2010:  Book Review: Brigitte Gabriel, “They Must be Stopped”. 2009. 240 pages.

3/1/2010:  Book Review; M. A. Khan “Islamic Jihad: A Legacy of Forced Conversion, Imperialism and Slavery”

2/22/2010:  Book Review: 'Defeating Political Islam' by Moorthy Muthuswamy

2/13/2010:  'Holy Warriors' – the Arab devastation of the Mediterranean

2/10/2010:  Henri Pirenne and why the 'Dark Ages' occurred.

2/20/2009:  Book Review: 'The Great Arab Conquests', by Hugh Kennedy.

1/22/2009:  Book Review - 'Chasing a Mirage' by Tarek Fatah. [2008, Wiley and Son, 410 pages.]

6/15/2008:  Book Review: 'Islamic Imperialism – A History.' By Efraim Karsh.

1/7/2008:  Book Review: Ed Husain, 'The Islamist'

11/22/2007:  Book Review: 'The War of Ideas: Jihadism against Democracy', by Walid Phares

10/16/2007:  Robert Spencer's superb book: 'Religion of Peace: Why Christianity is and Islam isn't'

9/21/2007:  Book Review: 'Infidel' by Ayaan Hirsi Ali- a Somalian-Dutch Muslim Apostate

5/2/2007:  Book Review: Islam The Arab Imperialism, By Anwar Shaikh

4/9/2007:  Book Review: ‘Religion of Peace? Islam’s War Against the World’, by G.M. Davis

2/12/2007:  Book review – ‘The Truth about Mohammad’, by Robert Spencer

2/11/2007:  Book review of 'Because they hate' by Brigitte Gabriel