French    German    Spain    Italian    Arabic    Chinese Simplified    Russian

Western Civilisation

Until the advent of materialism and 19th c. dogma, Western Civilisation was  superior to anything Islam had developed.  Islam has not aided in the development of the modern world; in fact civilisation has only been created in spite of Islam.  Proof of this resides in the 'modern' world and the unending political-economic and spiritual poverty of Muslim states and regions.  Squatting on richer civilisations is not 'progress'.  Islam is pagan, totalitarian, and irrational.   

Back     Printer Friendly Version  

Tuesday, September 16, 2014

Bid'ah and the law against innovation in Islam

Prohibition against any practice which offends Muhammad.

by Ferdinand III



Contrary to mainstream opinion, Islam of itself, by itself, invented little to nothing. Only in astrology can we find some contributions from Arab-Moslems or Persian-Moslems. In everything else it was either the Dhimmi population with Moslem names who carried on progress – stunted as it was under a dogmatic fascism post 1000 AD – or nothing occurred. Why wasn't the blast furnace, optical lenses, the scientific method, chimneys, modern mirrors, gravity-based machines, water mills, or wind mills created in Dar-al-Islam ? Innovation is not embraced that is why.



From Imam Bukhari's chapter on Ihtisam I learnt that innovation was anti-Islamic. The concept is called Bid'ah or a new thing. Muhammad commanded his followers to be knaves and slaves following his orders.



“…so cling to my Sunnah and the Sunnah of the rightly guided caliphsafter me, even if it be with your teeth” [Bukhari]



and



[???????? ???????? ??? ???? ????????]

And among the worst deeds is to invent new things and every innovation is misguidance. [source]



This is clearly a problem for Islam. Innovation is not to be embraced.



Moslems now of course 'parse' the word 'Bid'ah' to give it 2 meanings, namely, 'good innovation' and 'bad innovation'. But these modern appellations are not what you find in Mein Hadith from Bukhari, nor indeed in Mein Koran. What the reader finds in the foundational texts are commands to follow Muhammad's every word, deed and path or Sunnah. In this vein Muhammad supersedes Jesus Christ who told his followers 'I am the way' and 'No one gets to the Father but through me'. Thus Christology is replaced with Muhammadology. And this is definitely part of the Koran's main and central themes. Muhammad usurps Christ.



In Bukhari's Hadith and in the writings of many other Imam's there is the story of Muhammad and his friends, sitting around, making promises to the Allah-thing [Baal the moon deity]. The 'great man' Muhammad was listening. One of his friends apparently said: 'I will make prayers (Salaah) all night long.' A second promised: 'I will fast (sawm) all the time.' The third offered: 'I will never marry.' Muhammad was unimpressed. Apparently he stated: 'I am the most God conscious of Allah (Ta`ala) than any of you. I pray (Salaah,) I fast (sawm) as well, and I do marry woman too. And who so turns his face from my Sunnah, cannot be of my Ummah'. 



If you don't follow my way, you cannot be in my community. The implication is clear. Don't do anything that I have not commanded or allowed. In other words, innovations in and around the Koran, Hadith, ritual, practices or culture are not permitted in Islam. This indicates that those hoping for an Islamic Reformation are deluded.



Bukhari's Hadith chapter Ihtisam goes even further into neutering innovation. He writes that innovations make a person a Murtad (a non believer.) A few examples given are a person claiming to be a Prophet, deny giving Zakaat [centralized tax to the Moslem state], performing the pilgrimage [Hajj] at a place other than the Ka'ba shrine in Mecca, or to introduce any other new belief which is in opposition to Qur'an or Ahadith. In other words the entire corpus of Christianity makes its followers Murtad, and by Koranic definition they must be killed [see Suras, 9, 5, 4, 8 and 2].



Bid'ah is a 'law' which prohibits any idea from being implement, which is contrary to the Koran, or the way of Muhammad. This ossifies the cult of Islam and paralyses it. No Giotto, no Vivaldi, no invention of steam or combustion, no innovations in medicine, chemistry or electro-magnetism. No art to speak of. Simply the theft of other civilization's artifacts and the pronouncement that 'Moslems did it'. Meagre, pathetic, untutored.

More Info on Bidah




Article Comments:

Related Articles:

Hadith


7/6/2021:  Hadith are supposedly divinely inspired. So too was Nazi theology.

6/28/2021:  Hadith, Jihad, killing children, murdering Infidels

12/11/2014:  Patrick Haley on the barren emptiness of the Hadith and Muhammadism

12/9/2014:  Mein Hadith and Dhimmitude

12/7/2014:  Bronze Age Dictums of Mein Hadith

12/5/2014:  Mein Hadith. Mein Sharia Barbarism.

12/4/2014:  Bukhari's Hadith and the 300 verses of violence and Jihad

12/2/2014:  Mein Hadith, Mein Koran. Kill the Jews and Christians.

11/26/2014:  Muhammad and the Allah idol. Follow Muhammad or else.

11/25/2014:  Muhammad the Psychopath and the will to power and rule

11/18/2014:  Mein Hadith, the Jizya head-tax, plunder and attracting followers.

11/17/2014:  Mein Hadith - Join Muhammad's cult and get your 'fair share' of booty and property

11/13/2014:  Moslem Hell-fire, science, medicine, burning of Infidels and the Magnificent 19

11/3/2014:  Muhammad the ever generous divider of booty and pillage.....

10/28/2014:  Murder, Jihad, Conquering the enemy - Bukhari and Muhammad's actions of war

10/28/2014:  Bukhari: Muhammad and booty

10/25/2014:  Hadith confirm that Muhammad murdered women, children and old men - of the Polytheists

10/22/2014:  Bukhari and Muhammad's doctrine of terror and Moslem supremacism

10/20/2014:  Bukhari Book 4 Hadith – Jihad forever ! Allegiance only to Allah [and Muhammad].

10/18/2014:  Bukhari and Muhammad's tactics in war.

10/14/2014:  Bukhari, Book 4 of the Hadith and Muhammad as war leader of the Moslem Jihad

10/12/2014:  Bukhari, Kathir and the necessity of Jihad and killing Infidels

10/9/2014:  Bukhari's Hadith Book 4 and Muhammad as Jihad commander

10/7/2014:  Bukhari's Hadith Book 4 and the demand for Jihad all the time.

10/6/2014:  Bukhari's Hadith and the demands for endless Jihad against the Infidel

10/3/2014:  Bukhari Hadith; 2nd part of Book 3 and Moslem supremacism and violence

10/2/2014:  Bukhari and Muhammad killing and murdering

9/30/2014:  Bukhari and the 'Hotel California' Hadith - no checking out of Muhammad's cult - ever.

9/29/2014:  Bukhari and the demand for Jihad, violence, booty and terror

9/22/2014:  Bukhari's Hadiths; Book 3 first part on the violence of the Moslem cult

9/21/2014:  Abu-Dawd and the necessity of Jihad

9/18/2014:  Bid'ah and Shirk, 2 reasons why Islam is so deformed

9/16/2014:  Bid'ah and the law against innovation in Islam

9/11/2014:  Bukhari's Hadith: Book 2 - Jihad, Fighting and paying Taxes

9/8/2014:  The Hadith make Jihad in the name of Allah both an obligation and path to salvation.

9/4/2014:  Bukhari's Hadith: 2nd half of volume 1 - the incitement to violence and supremacism

9/2/2014:  Bukhari's Hadith: First half of volume 1 - the incitement to violence and supremacism

8/31/2014:  Bukhari's Hadith and 4:52:196 - 'salvation through Mohammed' ?

12/31/2010:  The Hadith - as bad as the Koran.

3/14/2010:  Islam: drink Camel piss and be happy.