French    German    Spain    Italian    Arabic    Chinese Simplified    Russian

Western Civilisation

Join Gab (@StFerdinandIII) Western Civilisation was and is superior to anything Islam has developed.  Islam has not aided in the development of the modern world; in fact civilisation has only been created in spite of Islam.  Raising the alarm about the fascism called Submission since 2000.  

Back     Printer Friendly Version  

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Bookmark and Share

Robert R. Reilly, 'The Closing of the Muslim Mind'.

A must read for any who want to understand the communal cult called Submission.

by Ferdinand III


 




Reilly is a well known expert on Islamic and Arab affairs having covered the topics for some 20 odd years. Reilly is a long-time journalist, a meticulously professional writer and researcher, and a senior fellow at the American Foreign Policy Council, as well as a director at the Middle East Media Research Institute – an invaluable organization which shows the poverty of Arab and Muslim 'news' or propaganda. He has also served in the White House, the Secretary of Defense and in Iraq post-2003, advising the Ministry of Information. He knows his topic.

This is probably the best one volume compendium of information as to why Islam in toto, is a system of cultish belief with no basis or premise in rationality, the necessity of acquiring knowledge before engaging in metaphysics [a Jewish creation explicitly stated in the Torah many times]; reason through faith; or the moral division of church and state. There was a period when Western thought, expressed in Aristotelian theories and ancient Greek rationality, was beginning to synthesize itself with Islamic totality and doctrine. But that period was quickly effaced. Since the 10th century 'The Closing of the Muslim mind' has been a fact which has imparted enormous, deleterious and consequential effects for the world.

Many in the West, including the usual array of Communists, Marxists, and Socialists [rebranded as 'progressives'] will reject the truth of this book. But such people are not exactly enlightened to begin with. They are beyond help. For the rest who wish to understand why Islam became a ritualized, dogmatic, violent, jihadic and bloody cult, Reilly's work lays bare the theological and historical realities of Islam and especially of Sunni Islam which is the focus on this particular book [but much of what he said can and should be applied to Shia theology]. As Reilly states,

The radical voluntarism (God as pure will)....is hardly a recent discovery. St. John of Damascus, Maimondes, Hegel, and many others amply noted it. However the reason many Westerner today remain perplexed by Muslim behavior is that they are unaware of the fundamental theological doctrines that animate it.”

Most in the West don't want to know. It is easier to be lazy and hope that Islam just goes away. In this vein many simply demonize all religions [though Islam is a cult not a religion]; conflate Islam with Christianity [both are evil in this view with White Christianity the worse of the two]; and make-believe that Mohammed and Christ were the same personalities [they were opposites with Mohammed being what one could clearly call an anti-Christ]. Christianity has nothing in common with Islam.  As Reilly states, Islam was a political program to unite the Arabs and turn the endless Bedouin warring onto other non Arab tribes;

As the Qur'an enjoined, 'Hold fast, all of you together, to Allah's rope, and do not separate (3:103)'......Islam divinely sanctioned a kind of mega-tribal raiding of the rest of the non-Muslim world. 'Allah has promised you much booty, over which ye have not yet had power: (48:20-21)......According to this new revelation, it was now only right and just that non-Muslims should be subdued and ruled by the true followers of God. How to conduct these raids and divide the booty from them is an important part of the Qur'an (Qur'an 8: The Spoils, 59:6 The Mustering). The first biographies of Muhammad were titled kitab al-meghazi, the Book of Raids.”

It is obvious that historically Islam was a political-military project designed by Mohammed for his own benefit, to unite the Arabs, plunder and kill Jews and Christians and transfer wealth from richer more sophisticated Jewish and Christian enclave to the relatively poor and desperate Bedouin tribes. It was a project that most Marxists or progressives today, would certainly support.

The real issue with Islam, as Reilly details, is the lack of any form of reason or rationality in its theological program. The only era in Muslim history, which endeavoured to establish some form of logic and respect for cognition within Islam occurred in the early 9th century. It was named the Mutazilite movement centered in Baghdad, which;

...embraced the propositions that the mind can know things, as distinct from having opinions about them; that objective reality exists; that there is some purpose implied in its construction; that this purpose has to do with what man calls 'the good'; and that man's soul is ordered to this 'good', which is universal.”

A well known Mutazilite philosopher was Al-Kindi who was quite similar in many ways to Augustine or St. Thomas Aquinas in his desire to imbed reason, coherence and logic into Islamic doctrine, making the case that reason and faith go together, and are not opposites or antagonistic to each other:

“Al-Kindi's views (801-873) reflected the same rational orientation: 'Nothing should be dearer to the seeker after truth than truth itself.”

Thus for Al-Kindi and the Muslim rationalists, Islam was not a totality, that free-will and inquiry was necessary for a human to live both a cognitive and spiritual existence. It is exactly what the Christian Scholastics in Europe were also proposing – with great success.

The Mutazilite doctrine of church and state separation and the necessity to use reason to find faith, flowered for only 50 years. The Islamic counter-reformation was harsh and uncompromising. The three main schools of Islamic theology grouped as Asharism [after an important 9th century Sunni teacher]; and a fourth named Hanbalism [named after Hanbali an immoderate and extremist fundamentalist of the 8th century]; took over:

In the second year of the reign of Caliph Ja'afar al-Mutawakkil (847-861), the tables were turned....Holding Mutazilite doctrine became a crime punishable by death. The Mutazilites were expelled from court...and their works largely destroyed....the long process of dehellenization and ossification had begun.”

It took the Asharites some 200 years to expunge Mutazilitism from Islam. Some Mutazilite philosophers still appeared in the 10th and 11th century in the forms of Alfarabi, Avicenna, and Averroes. But they were weak and without followers in a Muslim world quickly cementing Asharite and Hanbalist fundamentalism into every aspect of Islamic life. Free will was destroyed. Rationality mocked. As Reilly explains – the destruction of reason became an obsession of the Asharites and Hanbalites:

The Asharite view developed a theological basis for the primacy of will by claming that the revelation of Muhammad emphasizes most particularly, and above all, two attributes of God: His uncompromising omnipotence and will. 'Allah does what He wills' (Quran 14:27). God's nature is His will...But the Asharite argument reduced God to His omnipotence by concentrating exclusively on His unlimited power, as against His reason. His 'reasons are unknowable by man.”

Destroying free will is the heart of a cult. You can't communalize your members and force them into obeisance, ritual, dogmatism and unthinking devotion, if you accord them the rights of reason, cognition and will. It does not work. Reason is thus the enemy of dogmatic cult belief. By establishing the impersonal thing called Allah as the prime mover of absolutely everything, Asharite Islam extinguished any movement and quelled any debate about injecting rationality into the 'uncreated' and most perfect Koran. Goodbye reason. In fact just suggesting that this thing Allah is not all powerful, soon became a blasphemy:

As a consequence of Asharite views, Fazlur Rahman said, the endeavour to 'search for ends and purposes in His laws is not only meaningless, but also grave disobedience to Him.' The theology of pure will anathematizes the search for rational meaning, 'Theology thus monopolized the whole field of metaphysics and would not allow pure thought any claim to investigate rationally the nature of the universe and the nature of man.'”

The second greatest Muslim in history is the Sunni Asharite theologian Al-Ghazali (1058-1111). In the 11th century he wrote two books, Deliverance from Error, and The Incoherence of Philosophy. Both are prototypical-Marxist/Hegelian works of morbidity and intellectual gymnastics and gibberish. But it resonated with Muslims who wanted a special relationship with a God which allowed no free-will. According to these pious Muslims, Ghazali demolished rational philosophy and science. The Sunni preacher's convoluted and mystical refutation of science effectively closed the door on Muslim rationalism. Averroes and others attempted to dislodge Ghazali's dialectical nonsense, but they met with no success and were even threatened with punishment and death by the Muslim state if they persisted in dethroning the thing 'Allah' from totalitarian control of all occurrences in the universe. By the 12th century the Muslim mind was collectively closed.

More from Reilly's book in another posting and why Islam is very similar to Nazism and Communism.


 


Article Comments:

Related Articles:

Islamic theology


2/21/2021:  Re-interpreting Muhammadanism? Rewrite Mein Koran first.

2/16/2021:  The 6 Pillars of Muhammad’s cult (not 5, there are 6).

3/13/2020:  Islamic theology demands a takeover of Europe.

3/12/2020:  There is no 'misinterpretation' of Muhammadism. Moslems themselves say this.

4/3/2017:  Sura 109 and Moslem supremacism. It is not a verse about peace and tolerance.

11/12/2016:  Suras 83 to 111; the madness and violence of Mein Koran refracted in Muhammad

11/5/2016:  Sura 82 and Cleaving Asunder [the heads of Infidels from their bodies...]

10/22/2016:  Sura 81 & Mohammed's madness. A psychopath as 'prophet'

10/14/2016:  Sura 80 'Muhammad Frowned' - at an Infidel who dared to ask him a question

10/12/2016:  Sura 79 and 'Those who tear out'. More rampant Infidelophobia.

10/5/2016:  Sura 78 and 'Great News', which is bad news for the world & non Moslems

10/4/2016:  Sura 77, 'Those Moslems sent Forth', must slaughter the Infidel

10/1/2016:  Sura 76 and 'Time'; time for Moslems to kill the Infidel, rape Infidel women, humiliate the Infidel

9/24/2016:  Sura 75 and Muhammad's Will to Power. Moslems rule, the rest will die.

9/19/2016:  Sura 74 and the Magnificent 19 angels of death who torture Jews and Christians

9/12/2016:  Sura 73: Every Moslem must fight for Allah

9/8/2016:  Sura 72 and Jinns, Pagan Islam, Bronze & Iron age rituals

9/4/2016:  Mein Koran, Sura 71: Noah was a Moslem ! Sounds like secular 'science'.

8/26/2016:  Sura 70, 'Ways of Ascent': half the chapter is hate speech against non Moslems

8/22/2016:  Sura 69, Mein Koran demands total obedience to its totalitarian cult.

8/19/2016:  Sura 68 'The Nun', there are no religious or monastic orders in the Meccan moon cult

8/5/2016:  Sura 66, Females are sex slaves, Infidels must be killed

8/2/2016:  Sura 65, Managing your females, and setting out the terms of divorce

7/30/2016:  Sura 64, Muhammad and Baal the iLah of Mecca, are uber alles

7/24/2016:  Sura 63 or 'Hypocrites', an 11 verse screed against Jews and Christians who are the enemies [63:4]

7/22/2016:  Sura 62 and Jew-Christian hate calling them evil, donkeys, stupid and liars.

7/19/2016:  Sura 61 or Battle Array. An entire chapter devoted to Jihad with only 60% of it being hate speech

7/11/2016:  Sura 60: Inspect, manage, control your women. Muhammadism has no respect for female 'rights'.

7/6/2016:  Sura 59, 67% is hate speech against Non Moslems.

7/1/2016:  Sura 58: Women pleading not to be divorced. Managing the female.

6/26/2016:  Sura 57 and forcing Moslems to give 'Charity' so the cult can buy Iron and wage war

6/19/2016:  Over half of Sura 56 are threats and hate speech against Non Moslems

6/13/2016:  3 stages of Jihad. 1400 years of the same pattern. Only the ignorant don't know this.

6/11/2016:  Sura 55, Moslem hate speech and intolerance means peace !

6/7/2016:  Moslem Liars and Taqiyya - 1400 years of mendacity sanctioned by Mein Koran

6/5/2016:  Sura 54 and 'The Moon'. Once again reinforcing the celestial-moon cult origins of the Meccan cult.

5/20/2016:  Sura 53: Baal the celestial idol is Allah, he represents the Dog Star and the Moon.

5/13/2016:  Sura 52 and more Christian hate

5/12/2016:  Sura 51: Demonizing Jews and Christians as evil criminals

4/28/2016:  Sura 50: Muhammad and the Allah thing uber alles

4/20/2016:  Sura 49: Supremacism, blind devotion to Muhammad and cult dogma.

4/10/2016:  Sura 48: Victory! Over the Infidel, the Jew, the Christian, the Pagan.

4/6/2016:  Sura 47: 'The Prophet', there is only Muhammad uber alles, submit to him

4/1/2016:  Sura 46: Anyone who does not follow Fuehrer Muhammad is a criminal

3/22/2016:  Sura 45 and Mein Koran uber alles

3/21/2016:  Sura 44: Smoke or Mist and lots of anti-Christian, anti-Moslem hate speech

3/16/2016:  Sura 43; More Christian hate from Muhammadism

3/12/2016:  Sura 42, Jews and Christians must submit to Muhammad-Allah

3/12/2016:  Yes Kufar, Islam does hate you. A lot.

3/8/2016:  Sura 41, 'Fussilat' and Moslem violence, hate and intolerance.

3/4/2016:  Sura 40 and more Christian hate.

2/29/2016:  Sura 39; Racism and anti-Christian hate speech all in one chapter

2/23/2016:  Sura 38 and Submission to Muhammad

2/19/2016:  Sura 37 and Islam's 'Angels' of death, violence and hate.

2/9/2016:  Sura 36 'Ya Sin'. Sin is the moon deity.

2/5/2016:  Sura 35 'Originator of Creation' - that is the creation of Moslem Fascism

2/1/2016:  Sura 34 and Moslem supremacism, everyone is born a Moslem ! Except those that Al Lah leads astray!

1/25/2016:  Sura 33 and the imperative of Jihad and hate in Mein Koran

1/24/2016:  Sura 32, science, Moslem logic and torturing Christians

1/20/2016:  Sura 31: Wisdom is Mein Koran. Mein Koran is wisdom.

12/23/2015:  Sura 30, Destroy the Christian-Roman Empire and all Christians.

12/12/2015:  Sura 29 and the real meaning of 'striving' within Islamic Imperialism

12/7/2015:  Sura 28 and Moslem supremacism. Christians are evil and must be killed.

11/19/2015:  Sura 27: Moslems will crush Christians like ants

11/13/2015:  Sura 26 'The Poets', the poverty of Mein Supremacist Koran

10/24/2015:  Sura 25 and the 'Criterion' to please the Allah moon deity and mad Moh.

10/10/2015:  Sura 24; Cover up the women, deny free-will, follow mad Muhammad

10/9/2015:  Sura 23, 'The Believers' in Mein Koran und Fuehrer Muhammad

10/2/2015:  Sura 22 or the Pilgrimage to venerate Muhammad and Baal

8/22/2015:  Sura 21; those who fought against the cult of Baal were actually supporting it

8/15/2015:  Sura 20, dialectical 'science' proves Moslem superiority

8/8/2015:  Sura 19 and Mary. Mein Koran and its gibberish, making Muhammad superior to Christ.

8/6/2015:  Sura 18, or 'The Cave'. More Jew hate and anti-Christian bile.

8/2/2015:  Sura 17: more supremacist ravings against the Jews.

8/1/2015:  Sura 16. Allah, Manna and his Bees

6/19/2015:  Sura 15: Christians are polytheist criminals

6/15/2015:  Sura 14, plagiarism, naming Jews and Christians as 'criminals', now deemed to be religious.

6/10/2015:  Sura 13 and hate speech, sure to titillate fascists everywhere.

6/3/2015:  Sura 11, destroy non Moslems.

6/1/2015:  Sura 10, kill those who leave Muhammad's cult

5/29/2015:  Sura 9 - Jihad is mandatory. For witless worms this proves Islam is peace.

5/27/2015:  Sura 8 - Kill the Infidel. Follow Muhammad.

5/20/2015:  Sura 7 and the madness of Muhammad's cult

5/18/2015:  Sura 6, Mein Koran, and violence against the Infidel ape and pig.

5/12/2015:  Sura 5: Hate and Kill the Christian

5/9/2015:  Sura 4 and Islamic Cult Doctrine.

5/8/2015:  Key to the Koran: It is dichotomous

1/9/2015:  Islam's terror verses. Mein Koran adjures terror against the sub-human Kufar.

12/20/2014:  Munafiqun, hypocrites and apostasy - punished by death.

11/8/2014:  The Meccan Moon Cult is saturated with slavery, violence, hate, supremacism, death.

11/1/2014:  5:32 and the lies of Moslems and their allies

10/30/2014:  Jihad is an obligation against any who dare even to criticize the Moon cult.

9/6/2014:  Jihad is an obligation to wage war against non-Moslems.

8/12/2014:  Why the Gospel is so deformed within the Koran

8/10/2014:  Forster and the 19th century Anglican view of Mahometism

8/8/2014:  Forster and Koranic plagiarism. Theft is now theological truth!

8/5/2014:  The Koran and Old Testament have nothing in common

8/2/2014:  The Koran is rather clear about ripping apart Jews and Christians

6/11/2013:  Moslem cult violence. Moslems never admit that Islam is simply Islam.

10/4/2012:  Moslem Fascism - akin to other modern varieties of the same.

10/8/2011:  Islam for Dhimmi's

7/28/2011:  Karahah or Hate in the Koran.

7/19/2011:  Moslems lying about Kafir or Kufr - Unbelievers and Slaves.

7/18/2011:  The Infidel

7/15/2011:  Koranic inspired racism

7/8/2011:  Shahadah – the 'first pillar' of the Moslem cult.

7/7/2011:  Muhsin, mindlessly follow the cult and you are 'good'

7/5/2011:  Fighting against the 'unclean' 'unjust' 'evil' Zalimun or Unbeliever

7/4/2011:  The Perverted Unbelievers must be punished.

6/30/2011:  Infidels and Hell-fire - 40 verses state that the Kufar is kindling for Hell.

6/29/2011:  10 % of the Koran focuses on Infidels burning in Hell......

6/27/2011:  Munafiqun - 'Moderate Moslems' must die according to the Koran.

6/24/2011:  Satan or Shaitun – in alliance with the Infidels.

6/23/2011:  Kabeen or 'Reward'. Guess who benefits from the Moslem cult?

6/22/2011:  The myth of Salam and Moslem peace.

6/21/2011:  Muttaqun – the 'pious'.

6/20/2011:  'War' in the Koran.

6/17/2011:  Jahiliya or Ignorance.

6/15/2011:  Koranic Ideology: 'Birr' or the 'Righteous ones of Islam'

6/14/2011:  Koranic Ideology – 'Najasun' and 'Rijsun' or the 'Ignorant and Dirty'

6/13/2011:  Koranic Ideology the 'Mushrikun' or the 'Dirty and Polytheistic'

5/31/2011:  Apostasy and the cult.

5/24/2011:  Al-Fasad and Mufsidun – the polytheistic, criminal trouble makers.

5/23/2011:  The Koran and 'Mufsidun' or the 'Mischief Makers'

5/18/2011:  Musrifun – 'The Profligate'. Meaning the Infidel

5/17/2011:  Mujrimun – the guilty, the sinner, the criminally indicted.

5/16/2011:  Furqan and the criteria of 'right and wrong'

5/13/2011:  Fasiqun - anyone rejecting the Allah-thing is evil.

5/12/2011:  Shirk - only Allah is to be venerated.

5/11/2011:  Zalimun; the division of the world between the 'just' and 'unjust'

5/9/2011:  Moderation within Islam without 'moderating' its texts?

5/3/2011:  Bin Laden is dead but not Islamic supremacism.

4/7/2011:  Blasphemy, Pastor Jones and Islam

4/4/2011:  Islam's universalist dogma

3/30/2011:  Islamic 'ethics' are not Western ethics.

3/6/2011:  Islamic theology demands Dhimmitude submission

3/2/2011:  The Theology and Arab 'culture' of Death

2/28/2011:  What is a 'Civilisation'? Can it 'hold'? Yeats had an answer.

2/21/2011:  Islamic Apartheid. Read Moslem theology and history.

2/20/2011:  Qaradawi: 'We will conquer Europe and America.'

2/16/2011:  The main question is this: Why is Islam a religion?

2/10/2011:  Al Ghazali, Qutb and Maududi. Read them to find out what Islam really means.

1/24/2011:  Sharia Barbarism is not 'Law'.

1/23/2011:  Creeping Sharia and Islamic Fascism.

12/17/2010:  Obi's email. An example of Muslim understanding.

11/13/2010:  Moderate Muslim Brotherhood - moderately pagan and Fascist.

10/27/2010:  Blame Islam for Islamic violence and supremacist racism.

9/20/2010:  The threat of Sharia – real and barbaric enough.

8/27/2010:  Islam and Taqiyya – lying to your face to advance Islam.

8/6/2010:  "We will conquer Europe and America", so stated Qaradawi, a Muslim 'moderate'

7/22/2010:  The myth of Muslim charity or 'Zakat' – money for the Umma not for the infidel.

5/20/2010:  'Draw Mohammed Day': Islam has no art and no higher culture.

5/4/2010:  Cultural allies: Islam and Marxism.

4/2/2010:  Reinterpreting Islam ?

3/8/2010:  Creeping Sharia and Islamic Fascism.

2/15/2010:  An ideology of 'Jew hate' is called a religion ?

7/9/2009:  13.500 Muslim attacks since 9-11 from an ideology dedicated to war.

5/26/2008:  Islam's universalist dogma

12/31/2007:  Islam's illogic is shown by Sufism.

12/1/2007:  Teddy Bears and Islamic intolerance

5/8/2006:  Bernard Lewis: A Sage in Christendom

12/6/2005:  Islam has failed its people and it has failed in the modern age

4/25/2005:  Islam is not a Philosophy of Peace but of Violence