French    German    Spain    Italian    Arabic    Chinese Simplified    Russian

Western Civilisation

Until the advent of materialism and 19th c. dogma, Western Civilisation was  superior to anything Islam had developed.  Islam has not aided in the development of the modern world; in fact civilisation has only been created in spite of Islam.  Proof of this resides in the 'modern' world and the unending political-economic and spiritual poverty of Muslim states and regions.  Squatting on richer civilisations is not 'progress'.  Islam is pagan, totalitarian, and irrational.   

Back     Printer Friendly Version  

Saturday, June 5, 2010

Bookmark and Share

Review, 'Medieval Civilization 400-1500' by Jacques Le Goff.

More Marxist cant and more than just a few anti-Western rants.

by Ferdinand III

Le Goff wrote his large essay on the medieval European world in 1964. For many years he was the President of the respected and very left-wing, French Historical journal 'Annales'. He was called during the 60s, one of France's pre-eminent historians on all matters medieval. So naturally one should expect to read an accurate account of the European-Christian medieval world; one based on facts, on historical probity and independence, and one free from the usual Marxist-Academic trash that informs such topics. After all this man is a giant, un homme de gestion of one of Europe's 'most respected' historical journals; and a person who because he is French must obviously be sophisticated, cultured and 'fair'. Mais oui ?


En fait, main non. Alas, Le Goff's book was far worse than one could even have feared.


There is plenty of detail in the book, in fact almost too much. It is rather a little too dense. There is no great 'theme' which unites the writing over various chapters, and there is no path through all the myriad points of commentary. The book is in effect a rehash – albeit a well researched one – of all 1960s cultural Marxist animus against both Christianity [which was in vogue during the Enlightenment and led Voltaire and others to coin the term the 'Dark Ages' to describe 500-1500 AD]; and European development over 1000 years. In fact one has to stop reading the book at a certain point. Le Goff's analysis and writing diverge so strongly from reality that it makes no sense to wade and cut your way through the waist deep foliage of innuendo, outrageous lies, and distortions.


Written during the seething irrationality of the 1960s narcissism; much of what Le Goff portrays as truth has been widely discredited in analysis since that period. Le Goff wrote the work as if he was a disaffected professor with a Marxist axe to grind against the supposed iniquities of Christianity. Le Goff obviously has a problem both with faith and with the mere fact that without reformationist Christianity, Europe might have ended up looking a lot like either Islam, or China. Le Goff is in other words a material Marxist and a man who can't understand, nor countenance the fact that Christian Europe created the modern world. He represents the lost path, the lost century of Europe, when it decided to become a self-absorbed, secular Continent and cut itself off from its cultural and ethical roots.


The reason why you have to stop reading the book just over half-way through, is the execrable array of lies parading as facts. Le Goff writes as though the person reading the book would naturally agree witih him. But even hobbyist historians who know the topic would see much that is wrong. Too many other investigations, writers, historians and archeological evidence are diametrically opposed to Le Goff's statements. Worse, little in the way of proof is offered -- no statements are sourced and referenced -- and in fact, much of what he proffers is fantastically wrong, including:

After the [thankful] 'decline and Fall' of Rome:

“Gold coins barely circulated any longer, and when they were struck by Merovingian rulers, it was chiefly so that they could display their status....”

“Medieval Christianity was to turn the desire to escape from one's lot into a major sin.”

“...that the total number of barbarians after their settlement in the Roman west formed 5 per cent of the whole population....” [it was 20% or more in the affected areas along the Rhine-Danube axis]

Christian European stupidity:

“There was a decline in the skills which was to leave the medieval west deprived for a long time. No one any longer knew how to quarry, transports, or work stone...The art of glassmaking in the Rhineland disappeared...Artistic taste...underwent a regression as did morals...”

“The crisis [of the feudal world during the 14th century or more accurately crises] gave birth to the society of the Renaissance and modern times which were more open and, for many, happier than the stifling feudal society.”

“War which was an evil between Christians, was a duty against non-Christians. Usury which was forbidden among Christians, was permissible to unbelievers, in other words the Jews.”

Innovations all came from the 'East'

“At the technical level it was transformed by borrowings such as the mill, windmill or watermill which came from the east...”

“Innovation in technology was, more even than elsewhere, a monstrous act, a sin.”

“There was practically no qualitative development in the use of machinery during the middle ages.”

“ the economic level it was for a long time passive with regard to Byzantium and Islam...”

“Contempt for the world...was one of the great themes of medieval thought.”


And on and on he goes. None of the above statements are true, not a one. The list of medieval inventions are massive – probably without parallel in history. Medieval Christian Europe was certainly not a society in which life was easy, wonderful, or entirely rational, but it was an evolutionary period of much activity, debate, violence and innovation in all areas of life from the spiritual to the economic and political. Ascribing to 'eastern domains' for example, as being the suppliers of all Western European inventions and technologies is viciously untrue. All of the above statements made by Le Goff are standard calumnies which are wrong, dishonest and evilly mendacious.


Adding to this disagreeable narrative, Le Goff spends very little time on the impact that the 1200 years of Islamic Jihad must have had upon medieval Europe. The idea of Holy War was a Muslim invention and taken up by Christianity in self-defence. If you want to kill a fanatic, you have be a fanatic yourself. The Mediterranean trade and cultural systems were completely changed due to the Arab and Muslim advance. Items like paper from papryus, imported from Egypt, simply disappeared inside Medieval Europe. Europe would never have developed the way it did – certainly not in the Southern regions at least – if Islamic imperialism had not existed. Yet Le Goff spends almost no time on this major thread of medieval European development.


Curiously Le Goff goes through page after page of the agricultural, urban and general commercial revolution[s] which transformed Europe from 600 to 1100 AD. But he never makes the connections or linkages as to why this occurred. He does say that agricultural productivity and land clearage and land use intensity rose dramatically. But he does not spend anytime outlining inventions, new tools, or techniques. It is as if the transmogrification of European life from the Oriental despotism of Rome to the Renaissance in 16th century Florence was bridged by a world of little progress, change or radical reformation. Common sense tells us this can't be so. Instead he spends a lot of ink describing worker unrest, coinage devaluations [by the Kings of France mostly to finance their wars]; class and urban dislocations. All are worthy subjects but they can't detract from the movement towards modernity experienced and witnessed by medieval Christian development.


I can well imagine Le Goff tossing back a few chablis with his tweed-jacket friends at Les Annales, smoking French cigarettes, wearing small glasses, and declaiming against all theologies which did not enshrine the Napoleonic ideals of state power, despotism, centralized and oppressive legal codification, or why the state needs to micro-manage all aspects of the political-economy. In this regard the medieval Christian period would be dismissed as not enlightened in the Voltairean sense; or perhaps during certain eras not centralized and brutal enough; or perhaps the thousands of inventions which Le Goff ignores indicates a too-free market place, broad trading patterns and open minds eager for change.


Whatever it is that he hates about Western society found its outlet in a book about Medieval Europe. But then again one should expect this distortion of reality from an academic inspired investigator who did manage a very left-wing French historical journal.


Summary: Don't read this book if you want to know the real story about medieval Christian Europe.



Article Comments:

Related Articles:

Books Reviewed

11/5/2023:  The Palestinian Delusion, by Robert Spencer

9/4/2023:  'The Templars', by Michael Haag

8/27/2023:  The Crusades, Christianity, and Islam, Jonathan Riley-Smith (2008)

7/30/2023:  Simon Webb: ‘The Forgotten Slave Trade; The White European Slaves of Islam’

7/5/2023:  Scanderbeg: A History of George Castriota and the Albanian Resistance to Islamic Expansion

6/29/2023:  Defenders of the West. Raymond Ibrahim. Another must-read.

6/21/2023:  A must read book, Raymond Ibrahim’s ‘Sword and Scimitar’.

5/29/2023:  Judith Herrin, ‘Byzantium. The Surprising Life of a Medieval Empire’.

5/26/2023:  Review: 'Byzantium and the Crusades', by Johnathan Harris.

5/18/2023:  Johathan Harris, The Lost World of Byzantium

5/13/2023:  History of the Byzantine Empire, Sir Charles Oman, 272 pages, 2018

11/7/2022:  Christopher Dawson 'Religion and the rise of Western culture'

8/26/2022:  Power and Persuasion in Late Antiquity. By Peter Brown

4/14/2022:  Henri Pirenne, 'A History of Europe: From the Invasions to the XVI Century'

1/22/2022:  ‘Through the Eye of A Needle’ by Peter Brown

11/28/2021:  Peter Hammond: Slavery, Terrorism and Islam. Exposing the moon cult and Jihad

11/14/2021:  The Rise of Western Christendom: Triumph and Diversity, A.D. 200–1000. Peter Brown.

10/4/2021:  Henri Pirenne: Mohammed and Charlemagne

9/27/2021:  Henri Pirenne: Mohammed and Charlemagne. Rome never 'Fell'. It was replaced.

8/9/2021:  The Catholic Enlightenment, Ulrich L. Lehner. Nicholas Bergier, defender of the Church.

8/8/2021:  The New World Order, by A. Ralph Epperson

7/15/2021:  The Catholic Enlightenment, Ulrich L. Lehner. From the 16th century to Pope Francis.

7/9/2021:  The Catholic Enlightenment, by Ulrich L. Lehner

3/29/2021:  The Clock and the Camshaft, J. W. Farrell

3/20/2021:  Bearing False Witness, by Rodney Stark, #2.

3/17/2021:  Bearing False Witness, by Rodney Stark, #1.

2/5/2021:  ‘Slavery, Terrorism and Islam’ by Peter Hammond

1/27/2021:  Emmet Scott 'The Impact of Islam' and the mythical Golden Age of Muhammadan Spain

1/24/2021:  The Impact of Islam, by Emmet Scott (part two)

1/20/2021:  The Impact of Islam, by Emmet Scott (part one)

11/20/2020:  The Light Ages: A Medieval Journey of Discovery, by Seb Falk. Science and sphericity.

11/11/2020:  The Light Ages: A Medieval Journey of Discovery, by Seb Falk

10/16/2020:  The Age of Plunder, by W. G. Hoskins

10/11/2020:  Michael Wood's 'In Search of The Dark Ages'. Plenty of light, the basis of civilisation

9/8/2020:  The Glory of the Crusades, Steve Weidenkopf (2014)

8/5/2020:  C.S. Lewis and 'The Abolition of Man' by Steve Turley

12/18/2019:  The Palestinian Delusion: The Catastrophic History of the Middle East Peace Process, Robert Spencer

12/11/2019:  Islam: Religion of Peace?: The Violation of Natural Rights and Western Cover-Up, Fr. Portella

11/25/2019:  2030: Your Children's Future in Islamic Britain, by David Vincent

4/28/2016:  History of the Catholic Church from the Renaissance to the French Revolution - James MacCaffrey

2/24/2016:  Morris Bishop, 'The Middle Ages'

11/6/2015:  “Medieval Lives” by Alan Ereira, Terry Jones and the 'other side' of the Monkish orders

11/6/2015:  Medieval Lives by Alan Ereira, Terry Jones

8/18/2015:  Dr. Robert Morey, 'Islam Unveiled' – The Real Desert Storm

8/16/2015:  R. A. Morey, 'Islam Unveiled', 1991

1/18/2015:  Ataturk in the Nazi Imagination, by Stefan Ihrig

11/28/2014:  The poorly named Enlightenment - James Hitchcock, History of the Catholic Church

11/27/2014:  Michael Coren's 'Hatred: Islam's war against Christianity' Read it.

11/20/2014:  "The Catholic Church and Science" by Benjamin Wiker

11/14/2014:  Michael Coren: 'Hatred; Islam's war on Christianity'. Stating the obvious.

11/11/2014:  Collins and Christian-Catholic Culture in the West

11/4/2014:  The Birth of the West: Rome, Germany, France, the Creation of Europe in the 10th Century P. Collins

7/25/2014:  James Hitchcock, The History of the Catholic Church

7/19/2014:  William Muir, 1868, 'Life of Mahomet' - the madness revealed

6/30/2014:  Garwood: 'Flat Earth' - a belief only held by atheists and evolutionists

5/1/2014:  How the West Won: The Neglected Story of the Triumph of Modernity by Rodney Stark

4/23/2014:  The Victory of Reason: How Christianity Led to Freedom, Capitalism, + Western Success - Rodney Stark

3/31/2014:  John Freely: 'Before Galileo', Kuhn and the real history of real science.

3/25/2014:  John Freely: 'Before Galileo', Diophantus to Bradwardine, review 2

3/15/2014:  Book Review: John Freely and 'Before Galileo'

2/19/2014:  Christianity, Islam and Atheism by William Kilpatrick (2)

2/18/2014:  Christianity, Islam and Atheism by William Kilpatrick

6/28/2013:  Raymond Ibrahim 'Crucified Again: Exposing Islam's New War on Christians'

4/24/2013:  Evangelical Catholicism: Deep Reform in the 21st-Century Church by George Weigel

4/21/2013:  Robert Spencer: 'Moslem Persecution of Christians'

4/13/2013:  Book Review: Islam: Evil in the name of God

3/31/2013:  The Triumph of the Risen. The Truth of Christianity.

1/12/2013:  Book Review 2: God and Reason In the Middle Ages, by Edward Grant

1/7/2013:  Book Review 1: God and Reason In the Middle Ages, by Edward Grant

1/3/2013:  The Early Middle Ages 400-1000, Editor Rosamund McKitterick, Short Oxford History of Europe

12/17/2012:  Heresy: Ten Lies They Spread About Christianity, by Michael Coren

12/10/2012:  Medieval Technology and Social Change, Lynn White Jr., Oxford Press, 1968

11/29/2012:  Book Review: Preachers of Hate: Islam and the War on America, Kenneth Timmerman

11/28/2012:  Book Review: Islamophobia, by Robert Spencer.

11/25/2012:  Part 2: The Gies' - Cathedral, Forge and Waterwheel, Review

11/23/2012:  The Gies': Cathedral, Forge and Waterwheel, Review.

11/13/2012:  Book: The cult of the Moon God, by Brian Wilson

10/31/2012:  Review 2: Islam Dismantled, Sujit Das, Ali Sina

10/29/2012:  Book Review 1: Islam Dismantled by Sujit Das, Ali Sina

9/22/2012:  Book Review: Michael Coren, 'Why Catholics are Right'.

9/3/2012:  Book Review, Why the West is Best, by Ibn Warraq, Part Two

8/29/2012:  Book Review, Why the West is Best, by Ibn Warraq, Part One

6/12/2012:  Book Review: Poitiers AD 732, Charles Martel turns the Islamic tide. David Nicolle.

6/6/2012:  Review 2: Diane Moczar, Islam at the Gates, How Christendom defeated the Ottoman Turks

5/31/2012:  Review 1: Diane Moczar, Islam at the Gates, How Christendom defeated the Ottoman Turks

5/26/2012:  The Early Middle Ages 400-1000, Editor Rosamund McKitterick, Short Oxford History of Europe

4/13/2012:  Review, Emmet Scott: 'Mohammed and Charlemagne'

4/10/2012:  Henri Pirenne, 'Mohammed and Charlemagne' – Part 2

4/7/2012:  Book Review: Henri Pirenne, Mohammed and Charlemagne – Part One

1/29/2012:  Andrew Wheatcroft's, 'The Enemy at the Gate'

1/22/2012:  Book Review: Defenders of the Faith, by James Reston Jr.

1/11/2012:  Book Review: Norman Berdichevsky, 'The Left is not always Right'

12/10/2011:  Book Review, Nigel Cliff's 'Holy War' – good but flawed.

11/7/2011:  'How Civilizations Die', D. P. Goldman, 2011, 270 pgs.

10/21/2011:  'Religion and the Rise of Western Culture' – Christopher Dawson [Kindle Edition]

9/29/2011:  Book Review: Bynum's 'Allah is Dead'

9/16/2011:  Middle Age Dynamism

8/13/2011:  Malise Ruthven, 'Islam in the World' and the Kabaa-Hajj paganism.

8/12/2011:  EJ Brill and the Ka'ba

8/11/2011:  F.E. Peters and the pagan origins of the Kabaa Shrine

7/14/2011:  Benjamin Walker, Foundations of Islam: The Making of a World Faith 

4/12/2011:  Martin Gilbert: 'In Ishmael's House: A History of Jews in Muslim Lands', part 3.

4/6/2011:  Martin Gilbert: 'In Ishmael's House: A History of Jews in Muslim Lands', part 2.

4/3/2011:  Review part 1: Martin Gilbert 'In Ishmael's House'. A History of Jews living in Muslim lands.

3/31/2011:  Book Review: Susan Bauer, 'The History of the Medieval World'

3/24/2011:  Book Review: Empires of the Sea, by Roger Crowley. [The Final Battle for the Mediterranean]

3/22/2011:  Book Review: Will Israel survive? By Dr. Mitchell Bard, expert on Israel's political-economy.

3/20/2011:  Book Review ‘The Great War for Civilization', by Robert Fisk

3/18/2011:  Book Review: Bruce Bawer's “Surrender: Appeasing Islam, Sacrificing Freedom”, Doubleday, May 2009.

3/15/2011:  Book Review: World War IV and Beyond, by Richard Hobbs.

3/11/2011:  Alan Dershowitz's: 'The Case for Israel.'

3/5/2011:  Leaving Islam, by Ibn Warraq

2/18/2011:  Review part 2: D. S. Margoliouth, 'The Early Development of Mohammedanism', 1913.

2/12/2011:  Review: D. S. Margoliouth, 'The Early Development of Mohammedanism', 1913.

12/21/2010:  Robert R. Reilly, 'The Closing of the Muslim Mind'. The Communal Fascism of Islam.

12/19/2010:  Robert R. Reilly, 'The Closing of the Muslim Mind'.

10/22/2010:  Rodney Stark, 'For the Glory of God'

10/20/2010:  Andrew McCarthy, 'The Grand Jihad, How Islam and the Left Sabotage America'.

10/18/2010:  Book Review: 'The Dhimmi. Jews and Christians under Islam.' Bat Ye'or.

10/8/2010:  Jamie Glazov: 'United in Hate'. Indeed they are. The Leftards and Muslims that is.

8/31/2010:  'The Stealth Jihad: How Radical Islam is Subverting America without Guns or Bombs', Robert Spencer

8/9/2010:  Amil Imani: Iranian and former-Muslim writes about the pagan savagery that is Islam.

7/15/2010:  Book Review: Baran's 'The Other Muslims: Moderate and Secular'. A fantasy novel.

6/29/2010:  Serge Trifkovic: 'The Sword of the Prophet'. Jihad, Jihad and endless Jihad.

6/28/2010:  Serge Trifkovic: 'The Sword of the Prophet'. The Madness of Muhammad.

6/5/2010:  Review, 'Medieval Civilization 400-1500' by Jacques Le Goff.

5/31/2010:  Fregosi and Islam's endless Jihad.

5/27/2010:  Book Review, 'The Civilization of the Middle Ages', by Norman Cantor, 1993.

5/21/2010:  Book Review: 'Islam's Black Slaves', by Ronald Segal, 2001.

5/9/2010:  Book Review: 'Race and Slavery in the Middle East.' by Bernard Lewis, 1990.

5/6/2010:  Book Review: 'Slavery in the Arab World', by Murray Gordon, 1987.

5/5/2010:  Book Review: R. C Davis; 'Christian Slaves, Muslim Masters', 2004 edition.

5/1/2010:  Book review: The Complete Infidel's Guide to the Koran, by Robert Spencer.

4/28/2010:  Book Review; Thomas Cahill, 'Mysteries of the Middle Ages', 317 pages.

4/9/2010:  Book Review: 'The Islamic Anti-Christ', Joel Richardson, 2009, WND Books.

3/26/2010:  Book Review: Wafa Sultan, 'A God Who Hates'. 2009, 244 pages.

3/19/2010:  Book Review: Brigitte Gabriel, “They Must be Stopped”. 2009. 240 pages.

3/1/2010:  Book Review; M. A. Khan “Islamic Jihad: A Legacy of Forced Conversion, Imperialism and Slavery”

2/22/2010:  Book Review: 'Defeating Political Islam' by Moorthy Muthuswamy

2/13/2010:  'Holy Warriors' – the Arab devastation of the Mediterranean

2/10/2010:  Henri Pirenne and why the 'Dark Ages' occurred.

2/20/2009:  Book Review: 'The Great Arab Conquests', by Hugh Kennedy.

1/22/2009:  Book Review - 'Chasing a Mirage' by Tarek Fatah. [2008, Wiley and Son, 410 pages.]

6/15/2008:  Book Review: 'Islamic Imperialism – A History.' By Efraim Karsh.

1/7/2008:  Book Review: Ed Husain, 'The Islamist'

11/22/2007:  Book Review: 'The War of Ideas: Jihadism against Democracy', by Walid Phares

10/16/2007:  Robert Spencer's superb book: 'Religion of Peace: Why Christianity is and Islam isn't'

9/21/2007:  Book Review: 'Infidel' by Ayaan Hirsi Ali- a Somalian-Dutch Muslim Apostate

5/2/2007:  Book Review: Islam The Arab Imperialism, By Anwar Shaikh

4/9/2007:  Book Review: ‘Religion of Peace? Islam’s War Against the World’, by G.M. Davis

2/12/2007:  Book review – ‘The Truth about Mohammad’, by Robert Spencer

2/11/2007:  Book review of 'Because they hate' by Brigitte Gabriel